Victor Davis Hanson rates the five best books on war/battle during the twentieth century. I agree with Hanson about John Keegan's The Face of Battle as the best book on warfare I have ever read.
As a youngster, I read a couple of volumes of The Literary Digest History of the Great War, put out in the 1920's I believe, and was struck particularly about the Battle of Verdun and the ossuaries surrounding the town, which I subsequently learned as a History major was the city in 839 AD where the division of the Carolingian dynasty's heirs was signed as a Treaty [of Verdun]. The middle segment consigned to the son Lothar became Lotharingia [Thuringia in Germany is an eponymous relic, I was told] in the middle of the Kingdoms which eventually evolved into France and the Holy Roman Empire [aka Germany for all practical 20th century purposes. According to famous Belgian historian Henri Pirenne, Lotharingia was the cause of much of Europe's strife, as Lotharingia encompassed Belgium/Holland, Alsace-Lorraine, Burgundy, and parts of Italy [now France] that were the objects of an endless tug of war between the precursors of modern France and Germany. Ironic that Belgium was the trip-wire for the Great War [Brussells now being the "capital" of the EU] and that Verdun was the symbolic killing field of the Great War, taking place where Pirenne said the original casus-belli sort of began over a thousand years before. The "Pirenne Thesis" was the shorthand that my college profs used.
I also read many books about WWII, including Guadalcanal Diary and the one I sort of liked the best, the unscholarly but fast-paced "To Hell and Back," by Audie Murphy. I read a book by Steve Ambrose and gained new respect for my godfather, who trained pilots to fly B-17s and my father-in-law, who flew on B-29s. [Both read my blog and kudos to you two!]
I used to read war books until after Vietnam, where I served for close to two years, and lost the appetite for such books for two decades, since when I have read several Ambrose books. Also Niall Ferguson.
"Much have I seen and known; cities of men And manners, climates, councils, governments, ...the fortune of us that are the moon's men doth ebb and flow like the sea, being govern'd, as the sea is, by the moon" [Henry IV, I.ii.31-33] HISTORY NEVER REPEATS ITSELF, BUT IT OFTEN RHYMES "There is a Providence that protects idiots, drunkards, children and the United States of America." Otto von Bismarck
No comments :
Post a Comment